Re: [討論] 四版兼職之小白見解
看板TRPG (桌上角色扮演遊戲)作者yukarjama (加島 裕)時間16年前 (2008/09/14 09:44)推噓11(11推 0噓 83→)留言94則, 8人參與討論串12/12 (看更多)
好像有人把兼職跟進階職直接跟PG畫上等號了(笑)
不知道為什麼會變成這樣,也許在3版的時候受到某種嚴重心靈創傷?
如果腦內補完就可以的話,其實也不需要武僧嘛,用戰士徒手攻擊就好啦
也不需要德魯伊嘛,用牧師改一下就好啦
也不需要詩人嘛,選盜賊然後魅力高一點就好啦,表演交給DM處理就好
也不需要遊俠嘛,戰士拿個弓箭配個雙刀加個自然知識就好啦
也不需要野蠻人嘛,反正戰士方便的很,跟DM說我被打到痛會狂暴就好
術士就更不需要啦,只是法術多的法師嘛,是嗎?
所以我們只需要戰、牧、盜、法囉
...那Wotc還賺什麼,科科。
事實就是,同樣是整整一碗的份量,有人喜歡吃爆漿蝦,有人喜歡吃灑
尿牛丸,有人喜歡混在一起作成爆漿灑尿牛丸。
說喜歡爆漿灑尿牛丸的都是喜歡暴食,會不會太偏頗了?
2版的DMG就有寫到,創造新職業的時候,先考慮原有的職業能不能符合
形象。只是後來這種概念一樣被拋棄了。
如果要做一個殺手/刺客,現在的做法變成直接做個新職業叫殺手。
不過殺手只能長這樣嗎?
也許殺手是單純的盜賊,只是強化暗殺和匿蹤能力
也許他強化了戰技和肉體訓練->賊兼戰士
也許他用魔法強化暗殺技巧->賊兼法師
也許他以神之名、神之力行天誅->賊兼牧師
混合上面的任何特質,在這之中就能變化出無數不同的樣貌。
平平是用魔法的殺手,A君可能盜藝更強,B君可能法術更多。A君可能
用魔法強化自己的殺傷力,B君可能用來強化自己的匿蹤能力。
C君呢?誰知道,說不定他養了一隻會咬人的超大倉鼠,甚至他自己就
可以變形成倉鼠。
關鍵就是「選擇」和在限度內達到「客製化」與「自由」,只要DM允許
、符合規則。只可惜這樣高彈性的設定後來被一些人拿去疊數字,被另
一群人視為洪水猛獸。
如果每次想到一種新概念就弄一個新職業出來,要不了多久玩家就要面
對滿坑滿谷的「基本職」,然後發現裡面有一堆長得像雙胞胎的hybrid。
更悲慘的是翻遍所有的職業找不到有興趣的,只能屈就現有的職業,還
得不停的催眠自己跟凹DM,這時候就不禁要問「當初為什麼不乾脆兼職
就好?」
--
"My character can out-fight the Fighter, out-cast the Wizard,
out-buff the Bard, and heal himself, too."
"Hey, no CoDzilla!"
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 220.135.142.58
→
09/14 12:08, , 1F
09/14 12:08, 1F
→
09/14 12:09, , 2F
09/14 12:09, 2F
→
09/14 12:25, , 3F
09/14 12:25, 3F
→
09/14 12:28, , 4F
09/14 12:28, 4F
→
09/14 12:30, , 5F
09/14 12:30, 5F
推
09/14 12:34, , 6F
09/14 12:34, 6F
→
09/14 12:35, , 7F
09/14 12:35, 7F
→
09/14 12:35, , 8F
09/14 12:35, 8F
→
09/14 12:36, , 9F
09/14 12:36, 9F
→
09/14 12:37, , 10F
09/14 12:37, 10F
→
09/14 12:38, , 11F
09/14 12:38, 11F
→
09/14 12:39, , 12F
09/14 12:39, 12F
推
09/14 12:43, , 13F
09/14 12:43, 13F
→
09/14 12:45, , 14F
09/14 12:45, 14F
→
09/14 12:45, , 15F
09/14 12:45, 15F
→
09/14 12:46, , 16F
09/14 12:46, 16F
→
09/14 12:47, , 17F
09/14 12:47, 17F
→
09/14 12:48, , 18F
09/14 12:48, 18F
→
09/14 12:48, , 19F
09/14 12:48, 19F
→
09/14 12:49, , 20F
09/14 12:49, 20F
→
09/14 12:51, , 21F
09/14 12:51, 21F
推
09/14 12:51, , 22F
09/14 12:51, 22F
→
09/14 12:52, , 23F
09/14 12:52, 23F
推
09/14 12:53, , 24F
09/14 12:53, 24F
→
09/14 12:53, , 25F
09/14 12:53, 25F
→
09/14 12:54, , 26F
09/14 12:54, 26F
推
09/14 12:54, , 27F
09/14 12:54, 27F
→
09/14 12:55, , 28F
09/14 12:55, 28F
→
09/14 12:58, , 29F
09/14 12:58, 29F
→
09/14 12:58, , 30F
09/14 12:58, 30F
→
09/14 12:59, , 31F
09/14 12:59, 31F
→
09/14 13:00, , 32F
09/14 13:00, 32F
→
09/14 13:01, , 33F
09/14 13:01, 33F
→
09/14 13:01, , 34F
09/14 13:01, 34F
→
09/14 13:03, , 35F
09/14 13:03, 35F
→
09/14 13:03, , 36F
09/14 13:03, 36F
→
09/14 13:04, , 37F
09/14 13:04, 37F
推
09/14 13:05, , 38F
09/14 13:05, 38F
→
09/14 13:06, , 39F
09/14 13:06, 39F
→
09/14 13:06, , 40F
09/14 13:06, 40F
→
09/14 13:07, , 41F
09/14 13:07, 41F
→
09/14 13:07, , 42F
09/14 13:07, 42F
→
09/14 13:08, , 43F
09/14 13:08, 43F
→
09/14 13:09, , 44F
09/14 13:09, 44F
→
09/14 13:09, , 45F
09/14 13:09, 45F
→
09/14 13:10, , 46F
09/14 13:10, 46F
→
09/14 13:11, , 47F
09/14 13:11, 47F
→
09/14 13:11, , 48F
09/14 13:11, 48F
→
09/14 13:11, , 49F
09/14 13:11, 49F
→
09/14 13:12, , 50F
09/14 13:12, 50F
→
09/14 13:12, , 51F
09/14 13:12, 51F
→
09/14 13:12, , 52F
09/14 13:12, 52F
→
09/14 13:13, , 53F
09/14 13:13, 53F
→
09/14 13:13, , 54F
09/14 13:13, 54F
推
09/14 13:14, , 55F
09/14 13:14, 55F
→
09/14 13:15, , 56F
09/14 13:15, 56F
→
09/14 13:16, , 57F
09/14 13:16, 57F
→
09/14 13:17, , 58F
09/14 13:17, 58F
→
09/14 13:18, , 59F
09/14 13:18, 59F
→
09/14 13:18, , 60F
09/14 13:18, 60F
→
09/14 13:19, , 61F
09/14 13:19, 61F
→
09/14 13:20, , 62F
09/14 13:20, 62F
→
09/14 13:21, , 63F
09/14 13:21, 63F
→
09/14 13:22, , 64F
09/14 13:22, 64F
→
09/14 13:22, , 65F
09/14 13:22, 65F
→
09/14 13:23, , 66F
09/14 13:23, 66F
→
09/14 13:23, , 67F
09/14 13:23, 67F
→
09/14 13:25, , 68F
09/14 13:25, 68F
推
09/14 13:52, , 69F
09/14 13:52, 69F
→
09/14 13:54, , 70F
09/14 13:54, 70F
→
09/14 13:54, , 71F
09/14 13:54, 71F
→
09/14 13:54, , 72F
09/14 13:54, 72F
→
09/14 13:55, , 73F
09/14 13:55, 73F
→
09/14 13:56, , 74F
09/14 13:56, 74F
→
09/14 13:56, , 75F
09/14 13:56, 75F
推
09/14 13:57, , 76F
09/14 13:57, 76F
→
09/14 13:58, , 77F
09/14 13:58, 77F
→
09/14 13:58, , 78F
09/14 13:58, 78F
→
09/14 13:58, , 79F
09/14 13:58, 79F
→
09/14 13:59, , 80F
09/14 13:59, 80F
→
09/14 13:59, , 81F
09/14 13:59, 81F
→
09/14 14:00, , 82F
09/14 14:00, 82F
→
09/14 14:02, , 83F
09/14 14:02, 83F
→
09/14 14:03, , 84F
09/14 14:03, 84F
推
09/14 14:03, , 85F
09/14 14:03, 85F
→
09/14 14:04, , 86F
09/14 14:04, 86F
→
09/14 14:08, , 87F
09/14 14:08, 87F
→
09/14 14:08, , 88F
09/14 14:08, 88F
推
09/14 14:09, , 89F
09/14 14:09, 89F
→
09/14 14:09, , 90F
09/14 14:09, 90F
→
09/14 14:11, , 91F
09/14 14:11, 91F
→
09/14 14:11, , 92F
09/14 14:11, 92F
→
09/14 14:12, , 93F
09/14 14:12, 93F
→
09/14 14:12, , 94F
09/14 14:12, 94F
討論串 (同標題文章)
TRPG 近期熱門文章
PTT遊戲區 即時熱門文章
-9
30
-65
138
34
86
46
153
28
65
14
45