[travian] 大型消耗戰﹣﹣步兵優勝論

看板CGI-Game (CGI Game)作者 (數字人生)時間19年前 (2005/11/02 15:16), 編輯推噓8(805)
留言13則, 6人參與, 最新討論串1/2 (看更多)
大型消耗戰﹣﹣步兵優勝論 用excel做了個表,將各族五種主要兵作比較,看出resource efficiency最高的是步兵 表1﹣﹣﹣攻擊 數字1是攻擊,數字2是所需物資,數字3是功效(越高越好, 數字1/數字2=數字3) Romans ------------------------------------------------------ leg________40_______ 440_______ 0.090909 pra________30_______ 460_______ 0.065217 imp________70_______600________0.116666 e.imp______120______1410_______ 0.085106 e.cae______180______2170_______ 0.082949 Gauls ------------------------------------------------------- pha_______15________315_______0.047619 swo_______65________535_______0.121495 t.thu______90________1090______0.082568 dru_______45________1090______0.041284 hae_______140_______1965______0.071246 Teutons ------------------------------------------------------- clu________40________250_______0.160000 spe_______10________340_______0.029411 axe_______60________490_______0.122448 pla_______ 55________1005______0.054726 t.kni______150________1525______0.098360 可以看到,攻擊力與消耗比率最好的是teutons clubswinger 表2﹣﹣﹣兵防 數字1是兵防,數字2是所需物資,數字3是功效(越高越好, 數字1/數字2=數字3) Romans ----------------------------------------------------- leg________35________440_______0.079545 pra________65_______460________0.141304 imp_______40________600________0.066666 e.imp______65_______1410_______0.046099 e.cae______80________2170______0.036866 Gauls ------------------------------------------------------ pha_______40________315________0.126984 swo_______35________535________0.065420 the________25_______1090________0.022935 dru________115______1090________0.105504 hae________50_______1965________0.025445 Teutons ------------------------------------------------------- clu________20________250_______0.080000 spe_______35________340________0.102941 axe_______30________490________0.061224 pla_______100_______1005_______0.099502 teu_______50________1525_______0.032786 對步兵最好用romans praetorian 表3﹣﹣﹣騎防 數字1是騎防,數字2是所需物資,數字3是功效(越高越好, 數字1/數字2=數字3) Romans ----------------------------------------------------- leg________50________440________0.113636 pra________35________460________0.076086 imp________25________600________0.041666 e.imp_______50_______1410_______0.035460 e.cae_______105______2170_______0.048387 Gauls ------------------------------------------------------ pha_______50________315________0.158730 swo_______20________535________0.037383 the_______40________1090_______0.036697 dru_______55________1090_______0.050458 hae_______165_______1965_______0.083969 Teutons ---------------------------------------------------- clu________5_________250_______0.020000 spe_______60________340_______0.176470 axe_______30________490_______0.061224 pla________40_______1005_______0.039801 teu________75_______1525_______0.049180 對騎兵最好用teutons spearfighter -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 210.85.106.212

11/02 15:27, , 1F
所需物資是所有資源合起來算,能力卻分開算
11/02 15:27, 1F

11/02 15:28, , 2F
這樣出現步兵比較有效率的結果是可以預期的
11/02 15:28, 2F

11/02 15:34, , 3F
不對,我說得好像怪怪的= ="
11/02 15:34, 3F

11/02 15:42, , 4F
把單一兵種的3項效率相加的話!?
11/02 15:42, 4F

11/02 15:44, , 5F
步兵好像會更有效率= =
11/02 15:44, 5F

11/02 15:44, , 6F
但是總覺得這樣的評估方式怪怪的
11/02 15:44, 6F

11/02 15:46, , 7F
除了速度快,超強騎兵應該還是有其他優勢可以算進"效率"ꄠ
11/02 15:46, 7F

11/02 15:57, , 8F
這是在消耗戰才合用的, 平常以能力總合高,食量少的為優
11/02 15:57, 8F

11/02 16:03, , 9F
總和高且食量少的還是步兵耶 騎兵很耗食物
11/02 16:03, 9F

11/02 16:54, , 10F
如果考量速度和攜帶量和食物的話, 我投高盧的TT一票
11/02 16:54, 10F

11/02 16:55, , 11F
攻擊力高又超快, 帶的東西又多, 而且不會很高級 = =+
11/02 16:55, 11F

11/02 16:59, , 12F
不過搶劫還是棒棒兵佔優...1/3 bonus就打死一票人了 = ='
11/02 16:59, 12F

11/02 20:52, , 13F
我突然發現其實clubswinger的防步兵能力不算很差耶....
11/02 20:52, 13F
文章代碼(AID): #13Q6VAdD (CGI-Game)
文章代碼(AID): #13Q6VAdD (CGI-Game)