Re: [情報] 民國無雙1.4測試丁版
另外說一件事,就是第三劇本的228事件
裡面幾乎完全採用台灣現行的"經典敘述",個人對這個說法一直比較持懷疑立場
例如說國軍登陸後"沿街掃射",實際上國軍當時是否有那麼多子彈可以浪費?
(當時還是美國對國府武器禁運期間,而且派到台灣的是裝備三流部隊,不可能有衝鋒槍)
整二十一師的裝備有多差,從它是川軍出身就可以想像
(傳統評價"機槍三挺打不響.兩挺不連放"是也)
雖然我手邊沒有資料,不過二十一師在台灣中部搜到日軍留下的幾門山砲還打報告要撿回去
(若根據維基,掃射是發生在台灣南部駐防國軍的過激反擊行動,並非大陸派遣國軍所為)
(換句話說就是交戰中的失控行為,而非派遣來台的軍隊蓄意進行)
個人建議敘述中加入幾件事實
1.調解委員會要求國軍"繳械",並且"建議"美國託管台灣(美方並未接受)
2.關於謝雪紅二七部隊的敘述,特別是一度佔領台中的事實
3.台灣南部地區發生的攻擊國軍事件,有國軍基地被圍攻三天三夜,部份據點還被攻陷
其中2.跟3.都是貨真價實的敵對行為,不管他們手上拿的是竹槍還是菜刀
(就好像新疆三區用的武器也不會多先進...)
1.則接近是另立政權的行為,特別是"解除武裝"跟"美國託管"(限制或剝奪主權)的要求
據此陳儀的報告雖然不實,但國軍高層"台灣人叛亂"的判斷並非全然不實
如此一來或可平衡傳統敘述中單方面指責國軍,完全忽視另一部份真相的問題
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.94.233.191
※ 編輯: ThomasJP 來自: 114.94.233.191 (03/26 15:01)
※ 編輯: ThomasJP 來自: 114.94.233.191 (03/26 15:04)
→
03/26 17:13, , 1F
03/26 17:13, 1F
→
03/26 17:13, , 2F
03/26 17:13, 2F
→
03/26 17:13, , 3F
03/26 17:13, 3F
推
03/26 17:18, , 4F
03/26 17:18, 4F
→
03/26 17:18, , 5F
03/26 17:18, 5F
推
03/26 17:22, , 6F
03/26 17:22, 6F
→
03/26 17:28, , 7F
03/26 17:28, 7F
→
03/26 17:57, , 8F
03/26 17:57, 8F
→
03/26 17:58, , 9F
03/26 17:58, 9F
→
03/26 17:58, , 10F
03/26 17:58, 10F
→
03/26 18:00, , 11F
03/26 18:00, 11F
→
03/26 18:00, , 12F
03/26 18:00, 12F
→
03/26 18:02, , 13F
03/26 18:02, 13F
→
03/26 18:02, , 14F
03/26 18:02, 14F
→
03/26 18:03, , 15F
03/26 18:03, 15F
推
03/26 18:23, , 16F
03/26 18:23, 16F
→
03/26 18:23, , 17F
03/26 18:23, 17F
→
03/26 20:24, , 18F
03/26 20:24, 18F
→
03/26 20:25, , 19F
03/26 20:25, 19F
→
03/26 20:26, , 20F
03/26 20:26, 20F
→
03/26 20:28, , 21F
03/26 20:28, 21F
→
03/26 20:29, , 22F
03/26 20:29, 22F
推
03/27 12:23, , 23F
03/27 12:23, 23F
推
03/27 12:29, , 24F
03/27 12:29, 24F
→
03/27 12:30, , 25F
03/27 12:30, 25F
→
03/27 12:38, , 26F
03/27 12:38, 26F
→
03/27 12:39, , 27F
03/27 12:39, 27F
→
03/27 12:39, , 28F
03/27 12:39, 28F
→
03/27 12:41, , 29F
03/27 12:41, 29F
→
03/27 12:41, , 30F
03/27 12:41, 30F
→
03/27 12:42, , 31F
03/27 12:42, 31F
→
03/27 12:42, , 32F
03/27 12:42, 32F
→
03/27 12:43, , 33F
03/27 12:43, 33F
推
03/27 12:46, , 34F
03/27 12:46, 34F
→
03/27 12:47, , 35F
03/27 12:47, 35F
→
03/27 12:55, , 36F
03/27 12:55, 36F
→
03/27 12:55, , 37F
03/27 12:55, 37F
→
03/27 12:56, , 38F
03/27 12:56, 38F
→
03/27 12:58, , 39F
03/27 12:58, 39F
推
03/27 14:31, , 40F
03/27 14:31, 40F
→
03/27 14:32, , 41F
03/27 14:32, 41F
→
03/27 15:28, , 42F
03/27 15:28, 42F
→
03/27 15:29, , 43F
03/27 15:29, 43F
→
03/27 16:18, , 44F
03/27 16:18, 44F
推
03/27 16:35, , 45F
03/27 16:35, 45F
→
03/27 17:40, , 46F
03/27 17:40, 46F
→
03/27 17:40, , 47F
03/27 17:40, 47F
→
03/27 20:00, , 48F
03/27 20:00, 48F
→
03/27 20:01, , 49F
03/27 20:01, 49F
→
03/27 20:04, , 50F
03/27 20:04, 50F
推
03/27 20:37, , 51F
03/27 20:37, 51F
→
03/27 20:37, , 52F
03/27 20:37, 52F
推
03/27 20:44, , 53F
03/27 20:44, 53F
→
03/27 20:45, , 54F
03/27 20:45, 54F
推
03/27 20:53, , 55F
03/27 20:53, 55F
→
03/27 20:54, , 56F
03/27 20:54, 56F
→
03/27 20:54, , 57F
03/27 20:54, 57F
→
03/27 20:55, , 58F
03/27 20:55, 58F
推
03/27 21:34, , 59F
03/27 21:34, 59F
→
03/27 21:36, , 60F
03/27 21:36, 60F
→
03/27 21:36, , 61F
03/27 21:36, 61F
→
03/27 21:57, , 62F
03/27 21:57, 62F
→
03/27 21:58, , 63F
03/27 21:58, 63F
→
03/27 21:59, , 64F
03/27 21:59, 64F
→
03/27 22:00, , 65F
03/27 22:00, 65F
→
03/27 22:01, , 66F
03/27 22:01, 66F
→
03/27 22:03, , 67F
03/27 22:03, 67F
→
03/27 22:03, , 68F
03/27 22:03, 68F
→
03/27 22:04, , 69F
03/27 22:04, 69F
推
03/27 22:10, , 70F
03/27 22:10, 70F
→
03/27 22:11, , 71F
03/27 22:11, 71F
→
03/27 22:14, , 72F
03/27 22:14, 72F
→
03/27 22:16, , 73F
03/27 22:16, 73F
→
03/27 22:16, , 74F
03/27 22:16, 74F
推
03/27 22:24, , 75F
03/27 22:24, 75F
→
03/27 22:24, , 76F
03/27 22:24, 76F
→
03/27 22:25, , 77F
03/27 22:25, 77F
討論串 (同標題文章)
SLG 近期熱門文章
PTT遊戲區 即時熱門文章
35
51