Re: [討論] RFC: The Sword of Islam
官網論壇的玩者Replacement迴響：
So I've been playing this mod ever since it was first released, but it wasn't
until I visited the newly re-opened Middle Eastern galleries at the Met
museum that I felt compelled to post my admiration for what you've made here.
Seeing the exhibit (which anyone with an interest in Middle Eastern history
owes themselves to check out if they're in NYC) convinced me that SoI isn't
just an exciting, beautiful, challenging game of Civ4, but it's the closest a
Civ mod can come to being a work of scholarship. I must have thought "hey, I
remember this from Sword of Islam" dozens of times while I was in there: the
Samanid pottery shards, the illuminated Shahnahmeh from the Safavid dynasty,
the golden astrolabe made by a Cairene artisan for a Yemeni aristocrat, the
engravings of Ottoman galleons, etc etc. Basically, you nailed the
distinctive historical identity of the overall time period and region as well
as the individual empires.
I think one of the main reasons the mod works so well is that it applies
Rhye's stability mechanic to distinct political entities, like the Fatamid
Caliphate or the Kingdom of Gujarat, rather than to amorphous
cultural-linguistic groups like the Arabians or the Persians or the Indians.
While I love the original RFC, I never really understood what was being
simulated when India or China "collapsed". But in SoI, it's clearly either
the wholesale destruction of an empire by invaders, or the end state of a
cycle of decline and exhaustion of "group feeling" as described by Ibn
Khaldun. In fact, SoI is an excellent accompaniment to a reading of Ibn
Khaldun, illustrating his historiographic principles beautifully.
So anyway, cool story bro and sorry for the long post and all that, but I
just wanted to thank you for all the work you put into this mod. Oh, and
comparing it to Civ V is like comparing Rembrandt to a kindergartner's
fingerpainting. Fingerpainting that crashes a lot and has crappy narration.
--
Schroedinger's cat is NOT dead.
http://sites.google.com/site/youtien/
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 118.143.20.164
討論串 (同標題文章)
SLG 近期熱門文章
PTT遊戲區 即時熱門文章
32
102