關於 Great Sable Stag 這張牌(counter問題)

看板Magic (魔法風雲會)作者 (TheCityof Papaya)時間16年前 (2010/05/21 04:42), 編輯推噓5(5012)
留言17則, 9人參與, 最新討論串1/1
我想請問的是這張牌:http://magiccards.info/m10/en/186.html ┌──────────────────┐ │Great Sable Stag │ ├──────────────────┤ │Creature ─ Elk │ ├──────────────────┤ │Great Sable Stag can't be countered.│ │Protection from blue and from black │ │ │ └──────────────────┘ 說明如上,從一開始得到這張牌就直覺認定可以用來跟藍色牌組對抗 但剛才在Xbox 360上跟外國人對戰 出牌的那一瞬間竟然被底下這張牌counter了 http://gatherer.wizards.com/pages/card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=189918 讓我整場對戰中耿耿於懷 是我解讀有問題嗎? 就連網頁上的說明也講的很清楚啊: 10/1/2009: Great Sable Stag can be targeted by spells that try to counter it (such as Cancel). Those spells will resolve, but the part of their effect that would counter Great Sable Stag won't do anything. Any other effects those spells have will work as normal. 10/1/2009: Although the reminder text doesn't say so, Great Sable Stag also can't be equipped by blue or black Equipment. 誰能幫我解答一下,是Xbox 360上的遊戲程式設計有誤嗎? -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 114.37.17.104

05/21 04:51, , 1F
應該是不會被反擊的....
05/21 04:51, 1F

05/21 04:52, , 2F
是被哪張牌反擊的?
05/21 04:52, 2F

05/21 04:57, , 3F
被普通的Cancel,我編輯一下文章,貼網址在文章裡
05/21 04:57, 3F
※ 編輯: ziliya 來自: 114.37.17.104 (05/21 04:58)

05/21 05:05, , 4F
應該是程式有誤......
05/21 05:05, 4F

05/21 08:50, , 5F
設計有誤 標準來說只有一張牌可以讓他進不了場
05/21 08:50, 5F

05/21 11:08, , 6F
請問 ekong, 是哪一張呢?
05/21 11:08, 6F

05/21 11:14, , 7F
Mindbreak Trap(殲智陷阱)
05/21 11:14, 7F

05/21 11:27, , 8F
喔~因為陷阱是 exile the spell, 不是 counter the spell
05/21 11:27, 8F

05/21 11:27, , 9F
瞭解~受教了!^^a
05/21 11:27, 9F

05/21 11:29, , 10F
規則上,不能被反擊的牌,還是可以拿康牌出來指,只是結
05/21 11:29, 10F

05/21 11:30, , 11F
算時不會生效(就是可以康但康不掉) 程式可能沒處理好
05/21 11:30, 11F

05/21 11:57, , 12F
假如場上有Guile 我用反擊咒語反擊 神鹿會怎樣XD
05/21 11:57, 12F

05/21 11:57, , 13F
字面規則上 鹿就變成我的了吧XD
05/21 11:57, 13F

05/21 12:01, , 14F
不會,Guile的能力發動條件是某效應"would counter a spell"
05/21 12:01, 14F

05/21 12:02, , 15F
但則神鹿則有"can't be countered"的能力,換句話說神鹿是
05/21 12:02, 15F

05/21 12:03, , 16F
"would never be countered by any spell",所以即使Guile在
05/21 12:03, 16F

05/21 12:03, , 17F
場上,也無法把神鹿劫咒劫過來。
05/21 12:03, 17F
文章代碼(AID): #1BzPx4JZ (Magic)
文章代碼(AID): #1BzPx4JZ (Magic)