[請益] 過水疑問
1.
手牌是23455條東東,其他已組好
聽5條東風對倒
此時對家打東風,過水不胡,選擇把東風碰起來打5條改聽25條
下一手隨即摸到2條可自摸嗎?
2.
本家手牌23條東東東北北,其他已組好
聽14條
此時上家打1條,因下家連四且已知有愛留大字的習慣
選擇用23條將1條吃起來打東風,改聽東北對倒
下家隨即摸牌捨北風,能胡嗎?
3.
手牌是23455條東東,其他已組好
聽5條東風對倒
此時對家打東風,過水不胡,選擇把東風碰起來打5條改聽25條後
上家捨1條用23吃進(先不論吃牌的合理性)
選聽4, 5條其中一隻單吊
此時聽4條下家即打可胡嗎
聽5條下家即打可胡嗎
煩請版友解惑
覺得問題很愚蠢的朋友們請多多見諒
我自己也覺得當然不行自摸/胡
但因為部份朋友說可以
所以我才會想上來求證
敬請海涵
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 114.40.197.176
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/MJ/M.1487698540.A.F54.html
推
02/22 01:36, , 1F
02/22 01:36, 1F
推
02/22 01:40, , 2F
02/22 01:40, 2F
→
02/22 01:42, , 3F
02/22 01:42, 3F
→
02/22 01:42, , 4F
02/22 01:42, 4F
→
02/22 01:43, , 5F
02/22 01:43, 5F
推
02/22 01:44, , 6F
02/22 01:44, 6F
→
02/22 01:44, , 7F
02/22 01:44, 7F
→
02/22 01:45, , 8F
02/22 01:45, 8F
→
02/22 01:45, , 9F
02/22 01:45, 9F
推
02/22 01:45, , 10F
02/22 01:45, 10F
→
02/22 01:47, , 11F
02/22 01:47, 11F
推
02/22 01:47, , 12F
02/22 01:47, 12F
推
02/22 01:55, , 13F
02/22 01:55, 13F
※ 編輯: epiphyte (114.40.197.176), 02/22/2017 02:04:01
※ 編輯: epiphyte (223.138.164.186), 02/22/2017 02:13:36
推
02/22 09:51, , 14F
02/22 09:51, 14F
推
02/22 10:25, , 15F
02/22 10:25, 15F
推
02/22 12:04, , 16F
02/22 12:04, 16F
推
02/22 12:50, , 17F
02/22 12:50, 17F
※ 編輯: epiphyte (223.138.164.184), 02/22/2017 13:22:19
推
02/22 13:15, , 18F
02/22 13:15, 18F
推
02/22 13:29, , 19F
02/22 13:29, 19F
→
02/22 13:30, , 20F
02/22 13:30, 20F
→
02/22 13:55, , 21F
02/22 13:55, 21F
→
02/22 15:11, , 22F
02/22 15:11, 22F
→
02/22 16:14, , 23F
02/22 16:14, 23F
→
02/22 16:15, , 24F
02/22 16:15, 24F
推
02/22 17:51, , 25F
02/22 17:51, 25F
→
02/22 17:52, , 26F
02/22 17:52, 26F
推
02/22 17:58, , 27F
02/22 17:58, 27F
推
02/23 10:02, , 28F
02/23 10:02, 28F
→
02/23 10:03, , 29F
02/23 10:03, 29F
→
02/23 10:04, , 30F
02/23 10:04, 30F
MJ 近期熱門文章
7
11
10
14
4
13
PTT遊戲區 即時熱門文章